Halk, oetinger, and brown, pllc

The Crucial Importance of Reserve Funds for HOAs: Lessons from the Surfside Tragedy

In the aftermath of the tragic Surfside condominium collapse in Florida, the relevance and importance of Homeowners Association (HOA) reserve funds are shown in a new light.

In the aftermath of the tragic Surfside condominium collapse in Florida, the relevance and importance of Homeowners Association (HOA) reserve funds are shown in a new light. As we piece together the lessons from this unfortunate incident, it becomes abundantly clear that adequately funded reserve accounts are a vital part of responsible HOA management.  Here are the most important things to understand about HOA reserve funds and how to properly plan for emergency needs in your association.

What is an HOA Reserve Fund?

An HOA reserve fund is a pool of money set aside by the association to cover the costs of anticipated major repairs, replacements, and improvements in the community. This could include repairing shared roads, replacing roofs on community buildings, updating community amenities, and more. These funds ensure that the HOA can afford to maintain and improve shared assets without the need for sudden, large assessments on homeowners. These funds help the Association to plan for large expenses and to preserve the property values within the HOA.

Calculating HOA Reserve Fund Needs

Determining the right amount for your HOA’s reserve fund requires careful calculation and thoughtful forecasting. All HOAs should hire a reserve analyst to develop a reserve study. The primary elements that a reserve analyst will consider include:

  1. An inventory of the shared assets that the HOA is responsible for maintaining.
  2. An estimation of the remaining useful life of each of these assets.
  3. The projected cost of maintaining, replacing, or repairing these assets.

The reserve study will help the HOA to determine the amount necessary to hold in reserves. An ideal reserve fund should have enough money to cover these projected costs without causing significant financial burden to homeowners in the form of unexpected assessments.  If your association is unsure if your reserve fund has adequately saved for future expenses, it is vital to meet with qualified financial planners and an experienced HOA attorney for a complete review.  Reserve studies should be updated every 3-5 years.

What HOA Reserve Funds Can Be Used For

HOA reserve funds are specifically meant for substantial, long-term projects, not for routine expenses like lawn maintenance, utility bills, or other operational costs. The key purpose of these funds is to ensure the financial stability of the HOA and to facilitate the smooth management of the community’s common areas and amenities. Reserve funds should be prudently invested, in vehicles that preserve the principal.

Lessons from the Surfside Tragedy

The Surfside condominium collapse in 2021 offers a sobering look at what can go wrong when HOAs neglect to appropriately fund and use their reserve accounts. The condominium, plagued by years of structural issues, failed to adequately address these problems due to a lack of funds. Over the years, the problems compounded and, tragically, resulted in the building’s eventual collapse and the tragic loss of many lives. This incident underscores the importance of proactively addressing maintenance issues and adequately funding reserve accounts to ensure the safety and well-being of all community residents.

The Importance of Legal Consultation for Arizona HOAs

Having an experienced HOA law firm review your current reserve fund strategy and emergency planning is crucial. Legal professionals specializing in HOA law can provide guidance on state requirements, and ensure that the board is meeting its fiduciary duties.

HOA reserve funds play a vital role in the preservation of a community’s integrity and the protection of its residents’ safety and financial well-being. The Surfside tragedy serves as a stark reminder of what can happen when reserve funds are not appropriately managed. We urge all HOAs to reassess their current reserve fund planning and consider seeking legal counsel to ensure they are sufficiently prepared for future needs.  Contact our firm today to schedule an initial consultation with our HOA attorneys by submitting your information on our contact us page.

Halk, Oetinger, and Brown shares this article for informational purposes only, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Halk, Oetinger, and Brown

Flat Rate General Counsel Services

Halk, Oetinger, and Brown represents hundreds of planned communities and condominiums throughout Arizona. We are different. We endeavor to turn legal services into a fixed cost. We are hostile to the billable hour system. Our attorneys and staff do over 90% of their work at flat rates. Our industry-leading collection program is at no cost to the Association. We focus on solving problems, not billing hours.

Flat Rate General Counsel Services for Homeowners Assocations
Flat Rate General Counsel Services

We Provide Certainty to Associations on Collection and Legal Services

At Halk, Oetinger, and Brown, we pride ourselves on our team of experienced attorneys who are dedicated to providing exceptional legal services. With our alternative billing system, you can have peace of mind knowing that you won't be charged by the hour. We have a successful track record of handling Covenant Enforcement, Assessment Collection, General Association Governance, and Litigation for Arizona Homeowner's Associations.

Innovative Fee Structures

Our unique flat rate monthly fees provide certainty to Associations.  Our  $50 per month client fees make legal costs consistent and cost-effective.

Assigned Legal Team

Every Association we take on as a client is assigned a dedicated attorney and collector.  Our team will understand all your Association’s legal needs.

Association Legal Services

From covenant enforcement to construction defects to inter-association conflicts, We provide the full range of legal services to our clients.

Assessment Collection

Assessment collection is the strength of our firm, but we provide a full range of services to planned communities and condominiums.

Halk, Oetinger, and Brown

$50 Monthly Legal Plan

Our goal is to provide general counsel services at a flat rate of $50 per month. This provides certainty to the Association regarding budgeting for collection and legal services. We offer a full range of other services for planned communities and condominiums, and general counsel. We offer a different kind of collections.

Flat Rate General Counsel Services for Homeowners Assocations
Experienced Arizona HOA Lawyers

Meet Our Legal Team

Our team of experienced attorneys is here to serve you.

 Philip Brown
Philip Brown
Founding Member

PB teaches classes on Enforcing the Covenants, Budgets, Effective Meetings, Reserves and Collecting Assessments

Kelly Oetinger
Kelly Oetinger
Member

Kelly practices in all areas of community association law with a focus on general counsel issues and covenant enforcement

John Halk
John Halk
Member

John Halk manages litigation cases for the firm in both the Phoenix and Tucson Offices. John is licensed to practice law in Arizona and has worked in real estate and collections since 2015.

Andrea Miska
Andrea Miska
Associate Attorney

Andrea Miska joined Halk, Oetinger and Brown in 2024 and her practice focuses on civil litigation matters.

Halk, Oetinger, and Brown

Assessment Collection Services via a Contingent Fee Retainer

Our firm offers a contingent fee retainer where we collect assessments for no charge to your Association. We believe delinquent homeowners should pay for the attorney fees and court costs for their failure to pay contractually obligated assessments, not your association. When a homeowner fails to respond to your management company or association’s letters and certified mail noticing them about your intent to send them to collections, we’re ready to take legal action.

Satisfied Homeowner's Association Clients

Read what our clients have to say about us...

"As an absentee owner my interaction with this law firm has been extremely professional. From their responsiveness and extensive explanation of an issue created by my tenant. They were very generous with their settlement proposal which I happily accepted."

Janelle Morris

"Phil is both a nice person and extremely competent with HOAs. Responsive and to the point he is a key part of your team."

David Peters

"Great response time. Seem knowledgeable. Glad we are doing our POA monthly retainer."

Jennifer Hensley